True Cephalopelvic Disproportion
by Jill Cohen
© 2001 Midwifery Today, Inc. All rights reserved.
[Read this article in Spanish: Desproporción Cefalo-pélvica verdadera]
This first-time mom was 43 weeks pregnant with a large baby. We went for an ultrasound
to ease her postdate concerns. That night she went into labor and her waters broke.
The labor was slow but smooth. Fetal heart tones were regular and mom was handling
everything quite well. I knew the baby weighed 10-11 pounds, but the pelvis felt
We reached transition after 24 hours of labor. When mom was ready to push I discovered
an anterior lip that I was unable to push away. The baby's station was -3. I had
mom squat while she breathed and I massaged the lip away.
Mom was pushing and fully dilated now. After one hour I checked mom again to find
the anterior lip had returned and was swollen. The baby was strong but the station
was still -3. We went back to deep breathing. I checked mom again in one hour to
find she was 6 centimeters dilated, the lip was normal, the baby was at -3 station.
After a 24 hour period, we had regressed. I told the couple and they understood;
we had a big babe. After discussing the situation, we decided to keep trying. We
went into the 32nd hour of labor with little progress. By this time sunrise was approaching.
We walked out to the chicken coop at the break of day, breathing in the fresh morning
air. We talked some more. Where did we want to go? A decision was made. We left for
the hospital. After arriving at the hospital mom was 8 centimeters dilated. With
the manual aid of the doctor she went back to full dialation. For 2 1/2 hours she
pushed with everything she had. Finally, the doctor, a compassionate man, informed
the parents that even though mom could continue to push safely there had simply been
no progress. Mom was tired and the baby's station was still -3. We prepared for a
I remember holding mom's hand while I stared, fascinated, at the doctor working
to free the baby from the womb. I distinctly remember how the baby's head looked
as the doctor lifted it out, how unmolded it was. I was sure this baby would not
have come through his mother's bones. He was a healthy boy, 10 1/2 pounds, strong,
sturdy, very clear. This was a true labor dystocia, a true cephalopelvic disproportion.
Everything I had always questioned regarding the medical establishment's management
of labor dystocia I was seeing with my own eyes.
Days later after sleep and much deliberation with myself, my assistant and the
parents, I came to the conclusion that the mom had worked gracefully, with little
resistance, to deliver her baby. We did everything possible to get her baby out vaginally
but in this case, it was not physically possible.
A few weeks later I was told by friends in the community that one of my peers
had remarked that this c-section was due to the mom's inner fears about birth. I
was enraged at my peer's comments. Why was I so angry? First, I believe one midwife
should not judge another midwife's actions, especially if she is not present at the
birth. Without knowing the couple, the baby, the mom's body, how can anyone gauge
the emotional or physical state of the mother?
I was angry also because I heard this concern through the community and not from
the midwife herself. Recently, I have felt a growing need to pull together with my
peers in my community to create positive power with other midwives.
However, this can never happen as long as midwives continue to judge one another.
It is necessary now more than ever for midwives to join together and learn from each
other. We must not allow ourselves to suffer from learning dystocia.
After I worked through my anger and was able to approach my peer calmly, I visited
her at her home. I gave her my account of the birth. We discussed the birth. We agreed
that the birth went as it was supposed to. It felt good to share one on one with
each other. We moved beyond our particular dystocia with each other and birthed a
better understanding between us. We understood the need to talk directly to each
other to prevent miscommunication. This will help us on our path of midwifery.
Jill Cohen lives in Gates, Oregon, with her husband and two of her four children. After practicing as a lay midwife for 20 years, she has now returned to school to get a nursing degree. She has been with Midwifery Today since 1990, where she is associate editor of Midwifery Today magazine.
If you enjoyed this article, you'll enjoy Midwifery Today magazine! Subscribe now!